The Rock & The Hard Place

by Emily McClain

(FULL LENGTH) Alan Tully was convicted of the murder of Janice Beck in 1996 and has been on death row for 23 years, during which time he has maintained his innocence. His daughter Elsie receives a letter from the man who claims to have committed the crime and she attempts to use the information to exonerate her father. The insurmountable challenges of exonerating a wrongly convicted person drive her to the...

(FULL LENGTH) Alan Tully was convicted of the murder of Janice Beck in 1996 and has been on death row for 23 years, during which time he has maintained his innocence. His daughter Elsie receives a letter from the man who claims to have committed the crime and she attempts to use the information to exonerate her father. The insurmountable challenges of exonerating a wrongly convicted person drive her to the desperate position of threatening a man she believes could help free her father, with disastrous results.

  • Inquire About Rights
  • Recommend
  • Download
  • Save to Reading List

The Rock & The Hard Place

Recommended by

  • Matt Hoffman: The Rock & The Hard Place

    I saw a staged reading of this play at the 2023 Essential Theatre festival. It's a tightly written, suspenseful, masterfully structured drama -- but wait, is it a courtroom drama? a family drama? a psychological drama? Somehow Emily manages to weave together elements from multiple genres without losing pacing or thematic focus, and builds to a surprising, devastating ending that reveals costs of the death penalty we hadn't considered.

    I saw a staged reading of this play at the 2023 Essential Theatre festival. It's a tightly written, suspenseful, masterfully structured drama -- but wait, is it a courtroom drama? a family drama? a psychological drama? Somehow Emily manages to weave together elements from multiple genres without losing pacing or thematic focus, and builds to a surprising, devastating ending that reveals costs of the death penalty we hadn't considered.

  • Adam Richter: The Rock & The Hard Place

    A powerful, remarkable play about the death penalty and the costs it exacts from those around the convicted. Elsie's desperation is as understandable as it is hard to watch as she does whatever she can to save her father. This play should be produced often and everywhere.

    A powerful, remarkable play about the death penalty and the costs it exacts from those around the convicted. Elsie's desperation is as understandable as it is hard to watch as she does whatever she can to save her father. This play should be produced often and everywhere.

  • Lisa Dellagiarino Feriend: The Rock & The Hard Place

    Wow, what a great play. "The Rock & The Hard Place" follows a daughter trying anything and everything she can to get her wrongfully convicted father's sentence overturned before his execution date. In addition to being a compelling story with pages that practically turn themselves, it is a powerful reminder of how flawed the American justice system is. This is the kind of work that is a call to arms. I loved it.

    Wow, what a great play. "The Rock & The Hard Place" follows a daughter trying anything and everything she can to get her wrongfully convicted father's sentence overturned before his execution date. In addition to being a compelling story with pages that practically turn themselves, it is a powerful reminder of how flawed the American justice system is. This is the kind of work that is a call to arms. I loved it.

Character Information

  • Alan Tully
    Character Age
    50's, 60's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Male
  • Elsie Tully
    Character Age
    20's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Russell Wyatt
    Character Age
    20's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Male
  • Jeremy Hollingbrook
    Character Age
    40's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Male
  • Lauren Jacobson
    Character Age
    40's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Rashida Mahmoud
    Character Age
    40's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Asian/Indian or Middle Eastern
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Lance Matthews/Guard
    Character Age
    20's-30's
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Male

Development History

  • Type Reading, Organization Dramatist Guild, Year 2021
  • Type Reading, Organization Playwrights Thriving, Year 2021

Production History

  • Type Professional, Organization Essential Theatre, Year 2024

Awards

  • New Play Award
    Essential Theatre
    Winner
    2024
  • Risk Theatre Modern Tragedy Competition
    Risk Theatre
    Semi-Finalist
    2021