Evie and Star

In Evie and Star, a new memoir play by Audrey Cefaly (Maytag Virgin, The Gulf, Alabaster), twin sisters crash headlong into the American healthcare system—and each other. Starleen is a writer with a house, a child, and a manageable life. Evie is newly dead. Through a fractured memoryscape of flashbacks, phone calls, chorus-driven absurdity, and one unforgettable road trip, Starleen tries to piece together what...

In Evie and Star, a new memoir play by Audrey Cefaly (Maytag Virgin, The Gulf, Alabaster), twin sisters crash headlong into the American healthcare system—and each other. Starleen is a writer with a house, a child, and a manageable life. Evie is newly dead. Through a fractured memoryscape of flashbacks, phone calls, chorus-driven absurdity, and one unforgettable road trip, Starleen tries to piece together what happened—and what was lost.From Connecticut rehabs to Southern Walmarts to a Kafkaesque bureaucratic hellscape, the play tracks a relationship shaped by childhood trauma and a playground accident that altered the course of both lives. Along the way, Evie’s voice emerges not just as memory but as testimony—a furious, funny, unflinching indictment of a system that failed her.Darkly hilarious and fiercely tender, Evie and Star is a reckoning with grief, sisterhood, survival, and the stories we tell to stay tethered. Told through the lens of a stylized chorus, boxing corner men, and one woman’s final plea to a system that kept her on hold, the play pulses with love and rage in equal measure.

  • Inquire About Rights
  • Recommend
  • Download
  • Save to Library

Evie and Star

Recommended by

  • Kenneth Jones: Evie and Star

    This represents Audrey Cefaly at her most audacious and expressionistic: The story of two sisters tethered by blood and fondness and creativity, but torn apart by mental illness, substance abuse, time and mortality. A wildly theatrical cry of the heart that is an experimental director’s dream. A play about chaos and connection, wellness, woe and the wide-eyed wonder of being a sibling.

    This represents Audrey Cefaly at her most audacious and expressionistic: The story of two sisters tethered by blood and fondness and creativity, but torn apart by mental illness, substance abuse, time and mortality. A wildly theatrical cry of the heart that is an experimental director’s dream. A play about chaos and connection, wellness, woe and the wide-eyed wonder of being a sibling.

  • Brian James Polak: Evie and Star

    Everything Audrey writes is packed with an emotional wallop. Evie and Star has it threaded through each scene. As I read it I felt inside the story with these sisters wanting to help them because Audrey is better than any writer I know at created space for empathy when characters need it the most. With Evie and Star she has crafted a mesmerizing journey full of joy and love and sadness and life.

    Everything Audrey writes is packed with an emotional wallop. Evie and Star has it threaded through each scene. As I read it I felt inside the story with these sisters wanting to help them because Audrey is better than any writer I know at created space for empathy when characters need it the most. With Evie and Star she has crafted a mesmerizing journey full of joy and love and sadness and life.

  • Karen Saari: Evie and Star

    This play illustrates the raw, real feelings we experience as the loved one of an addict. The pain of watching them fail and suffer, the joy we experience when their true self shines though, the torment that is the unending loop of hope and sorrow. The loveliest thing about this tribute to the playwright's sister is that even at its grittiest, it's never maudlin, nor overly romantic. It's a record of the awesome reasons she loved her sister so deeply. Gorgeous play.

    This play illustrates the raw, real feelings we experience as the loved one of an addict. The pain of watching them fail and suffer, the joy we experience when their true self shines though, the torment that is the unending loop of hope and sorrow. The loveliest thing about this tribute to the playwright's sister is that even at its grittiest, it's never maudlin, nor overly romantic. It's a record of the awesome reasons she loved her sister so deeply. Gorgeous play.

View all 7 recommendations

Character Information

EVIE, MID-50S, FEMALE, TWIN SISTER OF STAR
STAR, MID-50S, FEMALE, TWIN SISTER OF EVIE
ENSEMBLE-2-3 ACTORS
  • Evie
    A twin, the fraternal kind—though you might not guess it now. Once bright and full of fire, Evie’s life has been chewed up by addiction, poverty, and the long tail of a childhood brain injury. She calls it her “broken brain,” but there’s nothing broken about her soul—only battered, bent, and barbed with humor. She’s loud, mercurial, emotionally raw. Her language is profane and poetic. She’s survived the foster system, the streets, and the loss of her children—one to the courts, two to adoption. And still she loves. Still she hopes. Still she sings along to American Idol. Her body holds the ache of a hard life, but her eyes still hold a glint of mischief.
    Character Age
    mid-50s
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Star
    Evie’s twin, though she’s worked hard to shed the resemblance. Educated, controlled, and emotionally constipated, Starleen has buried the mess of her past under a polished veneer of success. She’s a published writer, a homeowner, a woman who pays her bills on time. But underneath all that structure lives a deep and unruly love for her sister—and a pit of resentment she doesn’t know how to empty. She speaks with precision, but when pushed, her words crack with fury. She wants to fix things. She wants to run away. She wants to believe she’s not complicit. Her posture is upright, but her heart is tired.
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Everybitch
    ENSEMBLE (2 OR MORE ACTORS)
    This is a shape-shifting collective of performers who fluidly inhabit three categories throughout the play:
    The Machine – A shape-shifting network of bureaucratic voices—nuns, case workers, doctors, nurses, cops, and more. Unless otherwise noted, all secondary characters are played by the ensemble as The Machine: a faceless, shifting system of slogans, scripts, and polite harm. The Machine has no center, only nodes—each convinced they're doing their job. Their behavior veers wildly: explosive one moment, playfully absurd the next, then cold and clinical without warning. The tonal dissonance is the point. Stylized, surreal, and often chilling, their presence underscores the absurd cruelty of institutional care. Sometimes they try to help. That’s when they’re most dangerous.
    The Corner Man – Stylized, internal, relentless. Evie’s fight itself made flesh.
    The Joy – Personal, fleeting, real. The people and moments Evie is fighting for. Named figures from Eve’s personal life (e.g., Mike, RayRay, her son) belong to The Joy.
    Note: Each performer may embody nodes from more than one category over the course of the play. The roles shift, double, and reframe. The tension between these forces is the core of Evie’s world.