Cyndy had a hard enough time telling her family she’s a lesbian, she does not want to try to explain polyamory to them. So, rather than come out once again, her two partners — Maggie and Pen, a wilderness guide and a middle school science teacher — take turns coming home with her for major holidays. But when her sister’s boyfriend gets a job offer in Scotland, Maggie and Pen’s schedules leave Cyndy without a date to an incredibly last-minute wedding. Confronted with a thunderstorm, an off-white wedding dress, a mischievous cousin, and a lingering crush on the Maid of Honor, Cyndy finds the only two people who could complicate matters further are suddenly free — and they’re both on their way.

A guy wakes up in a Taco Bell-shaped purgatory, finding himself seated with a scruffy ferryman named Chalupa. As they wait for the order that will determine whether he is meant for Heaven or Hell, he recounts his life and ponders how to move on from past mistakes.