I Think We're Lost

by Peter Fenton

Inspired and disturbed by the characters, story, and setting of
PETER AND WENDY by J.M. Barrie

Full-length. A darkly comedic young adult reimagining of Peter Pan. In Philadelphia, when a despairing college senior processes his looming adulthood, he, along with his roommate's "perfect" fiancée, is pulled into Neverland through Peter’s seductive promises and Tinker Bell’s hidden agenda. With no one else to trust, the college kids band together as they work to resolve matters of their own identity and...

Full-length. A darkly comedic young adult reimagining of Peter Pan. In Philadelphia, when a despairing college senior processes his looming adulthood, he, along with his roommate's "perfect" fiancée, is pulled into Neverland through Peter’s seductive promises and Tinker Bell’s hidden agenda. With no one else to trust, the college kids band together as they work to resolve matters of their own identity and existential baggage as they uncover dark secrets lurking in Neverland's past.

A contemporary, darkly comedic feminist, queer not-quite sequel, not-quite adaptation, this is a play for young adult audiences about deconstructing gender roles, making authentic connections, and falling into the insidious trap of eternal adolescence.

read more
  • Inquire About Rights
  • Recommend
  • Download
  • Save to Library

I Think We're Lost

Recommended by

  • Sam Heyman: I Think We're Lost by Peter Fenton
    “

    I THINK WE'RE LOST is a time-hopping, magical, and inventive take on Peter Pan that explores the dangerous allure of never having to grow up. From the dark implications of a life defined by pleasurable stagnation to the heartfelt journeys taken by each of Fenton's characters, this is a play that will delight audiences and designers alike!

    I THINK WE'RE LOST is a time-hopping, magical, and inventive take on Peter Pan that explores the dangerous allure of never having to grow up. From the dark implications of a life defined by pleasurable stagnation to the heartfelt journeys taken by each of Fenton's characters, this is a play that will delight audiences and designers alike!

    ”
  • Adam Richter: I Think We're Lost by Peter Fenton
    “

    [2026-04-16]

    A great retelling of a classic tale makes you appreciate the source material all the more. A SUPERB retelling renders the original story unnecessary. Peter Fenton's "I THINK WE'RE LOST" is the latter. The familiar characters from J.M. Barrie's "Peter Pan" are all here, but they have a nuance, depth and purpose more profound than any adaptation I've seen before. Fenton captures both the joy and tragedy of never growing up, and finally gives Wendy her due. See this play if you can.

    [2026-04-16]

    A great retelling of a classic tale makes you appreciate the source material all the more. A SUPERB retelling renders the original story unnecessary. Peter Fenton's "I THINK WE'RE LOST" is the latter. The familiar characters from J.M. Barrie's "Peter Pan" are all here, but they have a nuance, depth and purpose more profound than any adaptation I've seen before. Fenton captures both the joy and tragedy of never growing up, and finally gives Wendy her due. See this play if you can.

    ”
  • Nora Louise Syran: I Think We're Lost by Peter Fenton
    “

    Warning: this play is not for children. It will yank anyone out of the zombie-like power of their delusions: Peter Pan Syndromes, Mother/Mermaid Complexes and the whatever it is that keeps us bound, needing to be set free. Favorite lines: "To live will be an awfully big adventure" and "Pretend I made pancakes." 🤣

    Warning: this play is not for children. It will yank anyone out of the zombie-like power of their delusions: Peter Pan Syndromes, Mother/Mermaid Complexes and the whatever it is that keeps us bound, needing to be set free. Favorite lines: "To live will be an awfully big adventure" and "Pretend I made pancakes." 🤣

    ”
View all 14 recommendations

Character Information

Cast of 6 or 9 actors recommended. Optional ensemble members can play Lost Boys and Pirates.

9-Actor Doubling:
1. Connor
2. Lindsay
3. Peter Pan
4. Tinker Bell
5. Maggie
6. Wendy
7. James
8. Smee
9. Flick/Eric/All LOST BOY and PIRATE lines

6-Actor Doubling:
1. Connor/James/a few PIRATE lines
2. Lindsay/Wendy
3. Peter Pan
4. Tinker Bell
5. Maggie
6. Smee/Flick/Eric/all LOST BOY lines/a few PIRATE lines
  • Connor Forsyth
    A senior at a Catholic liberal arts college in Philadelphia lacking confidence in his own identity. He is currently in therapy and wrote a story inspired by J.M. Barrie's PETER AND WENDY to process his feelings about growing up. He is terrified to graduate and just wants to say something that matters. Can double as JAMES.
    21
    Any
    Male,
    Gay,
    queer
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Man,
      Non-binary
  • Lindsay Plencner
    A senior at a Catholic liberal arts college in Philadelphia with a prestigious literary career ahead and an upcoming wedding. A "nice girl from Indiana" inwardly buckling under the pressures of being a woman in the church. She is engaged to Connor's roommate, Eric. Can double as WENDY.
    22
    Any
    Female
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Woman
  • Peter Pan
    A bubbly, carefree young man from 1950s London who wished to be a boy forever. He loves his girlfriend Wendy dearly and fears rejection, though he will unconsciously prioritize adventure and fun with the boys over anything responsible, which is to say his wish worked.
    20s
    Any,
    British
    Male
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      20s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Man
  • Tinker Bell
    The feral manifestation of Peter's wish to be a boy forever. This ultra-powerful fairy created Neverland after the wish gave them life, is bound to Peter's side until the dream is complete. Tinker Bell will do anything to keep the boy's dream alive, and that does mean anything. (For clarity, the script defaults to Tinker Bell as female, but please note this role can be played as any gender)
    Any
    Any
    Any,
    Genderfluid,
    Genderqueer or non-binary,
    Non-binary,
    Male,
    Female
  • Maggie Wratten
    A once wealthy London-based mother of two who has become a high-ranking official in Hook’s crew. She’s arrived in Neverland with a chip on her shoulder, desperately wanting someone to pay... but who? (This character is called MAGGIE in all public-facing material to preserve a significant identity spoiler about this character)
    50s
    Any,
    British
    Female
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      40s,
      50s,
      60s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Woman
  • Wendy Darling
    Peter's lost love from London, a wily, vibrant West End actress whose star was rising in the mid-1950s before she joined Peter and became Neverland's reluctant "mother". Can double as LINDSAY.
    20s
    Any,
    British
    Female
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      20s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Woman
  • James Hook
    Peter’s longtime rival from London who followed him to Neverland seeking revenge for a lifetime of mistreatment. Likes sailing and has a (thus far) unrequited crush on Wendy. Can double as CONNOR.
    20s
    Any,
    British
    Male,
    Male or masc non-binary
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      20s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Man,
      Non-binary
  • Smee
    Hook's friendly, if a bit dense, first mate. Smee is fiercely loyal to the captain as well as intrigued and confused by Hook. This role can double with FLICK/ERIC. (For clarity, the script defaults to Smee as male, but please note this role can be played as any gender)
    Adult
    Any
    Any
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      20s,
      30s,
      40s,
      50s,
      60s,
      70s+
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Man,
      Non-binary,
      Woman
  • Flick
    A lost boy plucked out of Wisconsin in the 1980s. Doubles as ERIC (Early 20s, male-presenting), Lindsay's fiancé and Connor's roommate.
    20s
    Any
    Male
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s
    • Actor Race/Ethnic Identity
      Asian, Pacific Islander, or Asian American,
      Black, African, Caribbean, or African American,
      Indigenous, First Nation, or Native American,
      Latinx/o/a or Hispanic,
      South Asian or South Asian American,
      White
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Man

Development History

  • Workshop, Stansbury High School's Stallion Drama, 2025
  • Reading, Rogue Theater Festival at The Flea (Off-Off-Broadway), 2024
  • Workshop, Fenton Productions, 2023

Production History

  • Professional, Pier Players, 2026

Awards