I Think We're Lost

by Peter Fenton

FULL-LENGTH DARK COMEDY/DRAMA. When a jaded, college-aged Peter Pan considers leaving Neverland, Tinker Bell pulls out all the stops to make him stay. She sends the newest Lost Boy and "Wendy 2.0" off on a secret mission to kill Captain Hook before the pirate finds Peter again. Along the way, the newcomers confront unsettling mysteries lurking in Neverland's past.

FULL-LENGTH DARK COMEDY/DRAMA. When a jaded, college-aged Peter Pan considers leaving Neverland, Tinker Bell pulls out all the stops to make him stay. She sends the newest Lost Boy and "Wendy 2.0" off on a secret mission to kill Captain Hook before the pirate finds Peter again. Along the way, the newcomers confront unsettling mysteries lurking in Neverland's past.

  • Inquire About Rights
  • Recommend
  • Download
  • Save to Reading List

I Think We're Lost

Recommended by

  • Ian Donley: I Think We're Lost by Peter Fenton
    “

    Peter Fenton's I THINK WE'RE LOST is a retelling of a classic tale with so much dimension for actors to explore the characters we all know and love, as well as some wonderfully constructed new ones. Fenton takes this classic story and the spins he puts on it has audiences thinking about what's at stake when we decide to grow up.

    Peter Fenton's I THINK WE'RE LOST is a retelling of a classic tale with so much dimension for actors to explore the characters we all know and love, as well as some wonderfully constructed new ones. Fenton takes this classic story and the spins he puts on it has audiences thinking about what's at stake when we decide to grow up.

    ”
  • Brigid Amos: I Think We're Lost by Peter Fenton
    “

    This play was such a fun read! Peter Fenton spins out Neverland's secrets in a way that kept me off balance and guessing all the way through. When the hidden truth is finally revealed, we are asked to consider how resistance to taking on adult responsibilites can cripple a person rather than free them, and the wasted years of what could have been a loving relationship is heartbreaking. Yet the playwright leaves us with hope for the young college students who have stumbled into Neverland. I highly recommend this for high school production. Oh, and Tinker Bell is hilarious!

    This play was such a fun read! Peter Fenton spins out Neverland's secrets in a way that kept me off balance and guessing all the way through. When the hidden truth is finally revealed, we are asked to consider how resistance to taking on adult responsibilites can cripple a person rather than free them, and the wasted years of what could have been a loving relationship is heartbreaking. Yet the playwright leaves us with hope for the young college students who have stumbled into Neverland. I highly recommend this for high school production. Oh, and Tinker Bell is hilarious!

    ”
  • Brent Alles: I Think We're Lost by Peter Fenton
    “

    It's hard to believe that someone could come up with a fresh take on Peter Pan, but Fenton does that here very effectively. A modern telling that still respects the history of the original work, "I Think We're Lost" finds new ground in terms of just what it means to "grow up." It's an interesting clash between the joy of childhood myths and the reality of what our advancing years and potential loss of innocence can mean to our overall world view. An intriguing read that would make for excellent stagecraft, that's for sure.

    It's hard to believe that someone could come up with a fresh take on Peter Pan, but Fenton does that here very effectively. A modern telling that still respects the history of the original work, "I Think We're Lost" finds new ground in terms of just what it means to "grow up." It's an interesting clash between the joy of childhood myths and the reality of what our advancing years and potential loss of innocence can mean to our overall world view. An intriguing read that would make for excellent stagecraft, that's for sure.

    ”
View all 11 recommendations

Character Information

There are no real artistic reasons for doubling. You can have a cast of as few as six actors if CONNOR doubles as JAMES, LINDSAY doubles as WENDY, MAGGIE doubles as BARRIE, and one actor plays ERIC, FLICK, and SMEE. WENDY and MAGGIE must be played by actors of the same ethnicity for the story to fully work, but otherwise cast as diverse as possible, Neverland is explicitly described as multicultural. You can add extras to the cast as Students, Lost Boys, and Pirates. If you want to give more opportunities for speaking roles, you can divvy up FLICK's lines for several different Lost Boys.
  • Peter Pan
    An upper-class Londoner from the 1940s who wished to never grow up. Has a big heart and is afraid of rejection.
    20s
    Any
    Male
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Male
  • Captain Hook
    She's a middle-aged upper-class London woman scorned, who has now assumed the role of pirate queen in her quest to find Peter Pan again. **Hook being female is a surprise that isn’t fully revealed until the end of Act 1. As the pirate, she speaks in a gravelly contralto which masks her softer, more feminine natural voice.** Doubles as BARRIE, Connor and Lindsay’s English professor.
    55
    Any
    Female
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      40s,
      50s,
      60s
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Female
  • Tinker Bell
    The fairy bound to Peter until his dream is complete and is determined to keep that dream alive at any cost. Written as a snarky, grizzled New York mob boss. Self-described as a gender-fluid agent of chaos. Can be played as any age or gender.
    Any
    Any
    Any
  • Connor Forsyth
    A senior at a Catholic university in Philadelphia who is clever and creative, but has an inferiority complex. He just wants to say something that matters. Doubles as JAMES, Peter’s upper-class London rival.
    21
    Any
    Male
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Male
  • Lindsay Plencner
    A senior at a Catholic university in Philadelphia who is ambitious, successful, and kind. A “nice girl from Indiana” inwardly buckling under the expectations placed upon her. Doubles as WENDY, Peter’s upper-class London girlfriend and Neverland’s reluctant mother.
    22
    Any
    Female
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Female
  • Smee/Eric Bennett/Dan Flick
    In the smallest possible cast, this actor plays all supporting roles: Lindsay's fiancé ERIC, Peter Pan's right-hand lost boy FLICK, and Captain Hook's firstmate SMEE. In a production wishing to have a larger cast, separate individuals can play each of these characters, and extras can be implemented as more Lost Boys and Pirates.
    20s
    Any
    Male
    Can be played by:
    • Actor Age
      Teens,
      20s,
      30s
    • Actor Gender Identity
      Male

Development History

  • Workshop, Stansbury High School's Stallion Drama, 2025
  • Reading, Rogue Theater Festival at The Flea (Off-Off-Broadway), 2024
  • Workshop, Fenton Productions, 2023