The Moth Man Cries

It’s October 1967, Point Pleasant, West Virginia. For Dellie Harper, life is a quiet exercise in obedience to her pious mother. But the quiet is shattered when a late-night drive with her cousin ends with a crash and a terrifying vision in their headlights: a colossal, winged creature with burning red eyes. The creature in the woods becomes a test of faith that threatens Dellie's fragile, forbidden love for a...

It’s October 1967, Point Pleasant, West Virginia. For Dellie Harper, life is a quiet exercise in obedience to her pious mother. But the quiet is shattered when a late-night drive with her cousin ends with a crash and a terrifying vision in their headlights: a colossal, winged creature with burning red eyes. The creature in the woods becomes a test of faith that threatens Dellie's fragile, forbidden love for a devout neighbor. Caught between a creature that cries and a God that condemns, Dellie must race to decipher the meaning of the Mothman, before it culminates in a devastating tragedy.

  • Inquire About Rights
  • Recommend
  • Download
  • Save to Library

The Moth Man Cries

Recommended by

  • Scott Sickles: The Moth Man Cries

    The very best horror stories are about everyday life. Yet for all of the characters’ ordinariness, Gibbs has placed us in the middle of a world unfamiliar to many – a family home in the Bible Belt. Leaving preconceptions at the door, Gibbs provided small town people whose tiny desires loom large to them. What struck me most was how Dellie and Rich Vitt’s challenge and accept impossible circumstances. Add a preternatural sorrow and the terror of seemingly unstoppable fate, and there’s homespun magic amidst exquisite horror.

    The very best horror stories are about everyday life. Yet for all of the characters’ ordinariness, Gibbs has placed us in the middle of a world unfamiliar to many – a family home in the Bible Belt. Leaving preconceptions at the door, Gibbs provided small town people whose tiny desires loom large to them. What struck me most was how Dellie and Rich Vitt’s challenge and accept impossible circumstances. Add a preternatural sorrow and the terror of seemingly unstoppable fate, and there’s homespun magic amidst exquisite horror.

  • Daniel Emlyn-Jones: The Moth Man Cries

    A terrifying and gripping play with masterly use of suspense. History and particularly colonial history is bathed in blood. Communities, families and individuals can also be colonised by ideas. For me the Moth Man is a visceral cry for vengeance, a fable and a warning. The mysterious, multitextured nature of this subject was handled beautifully. I saw a reading of this at the Valdez Theatre Conference 2026 and was on the edge of my seat.

    A terrifying and gripping play with masterly use of suspense. History and particularly colonial history is bathed in blood. Communities, families and individuals can also be colonised by ideas. For me the Moth Man is a visceral cry for vengeance, a fable and a warning. The mysterious, multitextured nature of this subject was handled beautifully. I saw a reading of this at the Valdez Theatre Conference 2026 and was on the edge of my seat.

  • Ken Love: The Moth Man Cries

    "The Moth Man Cries" by Marshall Logan Gibbs represents the best in storytelling from an American vantage point: an incredible mixture of myth, horror, parable, and heartaching drama told without a single false note. The characters are so well rendered and human that they breathe from the page as they carry this gripping tale from beginning to a satisfying end. I long for the time when I can see this work staged. Marvelously done, sir!

    "The Moth Man Cries" by Marshall Logan Gibbs represents the best in storytelling from an American vantage point: an incredible mixture of myth, horror, parable, and heartaching drama told without a single false note. The characters are so well rendered and human that they breathe from the page as they carry this gripping tale from beginning to a satisfying end. I long for the time when I can see this work staged. Marvelously done, sir!

View all 13 recommendations

Character Information

OLD DELLIE should be doubled with the actress playing RUTH.
MOTH MAN should be doubled with the actor playing RICH.
  • Dellie Harper
    Outwardly obedient, but longs for a more exciting life. Daydreams of Paul McCartney (and of Bonnie.)
    Character Age
    19
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Rich Harper
    Dellie’s charismatic, rebellious, and quick-witted cousin. His mouth gets him in lots of trouble.
    Character Age
    21
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Male
  • Dorothy Harper
    The pious mother of Dellie and aunt of Rich. The only thing she loves more than her daughter is her Bible.
    Character Age
    40s
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Bonnie Wright
    Dellie's neighbor and childhood friend, now caught in a hard place between her bond with Dellie and her religious beliefs.
    Character Age
    19
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Female
  • Ruth Waylon
    The town's librarian and a historian. A wise and witty woman of partial Shawnee descent.
    Character Age
    60s-70s
    Character Race/Ethnic Identity
    Any
    Character Gender Identity
    Female

Development History

  • Type Reading, Organization Valdez Theatre Conference, Year 2026
  • Type Reading, Organization Mercury Theatre, Year 2025

Awards

  • Alternate
    Great Plains Theatre Commons New Play Festival
    Finalist
    2026